She said, “He’s been impeached forever. They can never erase that.”
However, Pelosi has it exactly backward. The Senate is going to refuse to convict Trump. He will be exonerated, and she and the Democrats will be condemned by history.
The wide repudiation of the House Democratic betrayal of the Constitution is already beginning. As a historian myself, I think it’s important to document these reactions.
Consider historian Victor Davis Hanson’s analysis for the National Review, which was subtitled: “The new normal: Impeachment as a routine partisan tool, endless investigations, lying under oath with impunity, surveillance of political enemies, zero accountability.”
This is hardly an endorsement of Pelosi’s trivialization of the Constitution.
Abraham Lincoln scholar and highly respected historian Allen Guelzo asserted in The Wall Street Journal:
Clearly, Pelosi either did not know or consider the warnings of Pinckney and King—or the sad end of the impeachment process against President Andrew Johnson.
When interviewed by Arun Rath, Harvard law professor and ACLU liberal Alan Dershowitz commented:
When interviewed by Congress, law professor Jonathan Turley warned:
“So I think the House of Representatives violated the Constitution when they impeached him on these two grounds.”
So, from these perspectives, it is Pelosi—not Trump—who threatens to undermine the Constitution.
As former federal prosecutor Andy McCarthy pointed out on Fox News, the Pelosi strategy is simply to “bruise President Trump with an unending stream of new impeachment allegations” to hurt his chances at re-election. McCarthy added, “After over 230 years, we have entered the era of partisan impeachment that the Framers feared. This is what it looks like.”
So McCarthy sees Pelosi behaving in exactly the unconstitutional and narrowly partisan manner that the writers of the Constitution hoped to avoid. Again, it is Pelosi—not Trump—who is undermining the Constitution.
In addition, The New York Post’s editorial board noted that “Intelligence Chairman Adam Schiff has been lying to the world for years in his nonstop campaign to smear President Trump.” Their judgment is that it is Schiff—and not Trump—who has been a serial liar.
The Wall Street Journal’s editorial board summarized the disaster of Pelosi’s bid to delay sending the articles of impeachment to the Senate, saying her move “further exposes how Democrats have defined impeachment down. The House hearings blocked GOP witnesses and limited cross-examination. Despite selective leaks and a pro-impeachment media, they failed to move public opinion or persuade Republicans that Mr. Trump committed impeachable offenses.”
The Journal’s editorial board went on to call Democrats’ actions “an abuse of the impeachment power” and reiterated that the things alleged in the articles of impeachment “aren’t close to impeachable.”
Madison Gesiotto in The Hill called this “the flimsiest and most partisan impeachment in history.”
In fact, as Pelosi played games with appointing managers, even senior Democrats began to lose patience. “The longer it goes on, the less urgent it becomes,” Democratic Senator Dianne Feinstein told reporters. “If it is serious and urgent, send them over. If it is not, do not send it over.”
Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell neatly summarized the House-created calamity in his floor statement on Thursday, saying “it was a transparently partisan performance from beginning to end.”
McConnell went on to remind the country of the Founding Fathers’ fears of exactly the kind of narrow bitter partisanship Pelosi has been displaying. Paraphrasing Hamilton, McConnell warned that “blinded by factionalism, the House of Representatives would abuse the power of impeachment to serve nakedly partisan goals rather than the long-term interests of the American people and their Republic.”
Finally, it’s clear the House Democrats have failed utterly to live up to the standard of prosecution set out by former Associate Supreme Court Justice Robert H. Jackson (who served as chief prosecutor of the Nuremberg trials). Jackson cautioned the Conference of United States Attorneys on April 1, 1940:
So, no, Pelosi. Trump does not have to fear the judgment of history on this impeachment effort.
The judgment of history is going to be that a group of scoundrels in control of the U.S. House of Representatives placed partisan interests above the country, undermined the Constitution, weakened America in the world and lied about the duly elected president of the United States.
This will become Pelosi’s moment of shame, and Trump’s moment of redemption.
Former Speaker of the U.S. House of Representatives Newt Gingrich is the chairman of Gingrich 360, the host of the Newt’s World podcast and author of the New York Times best-sellers Understanding Trump and Trump’s America.
To read, watch or listen to more of Gingrich’s commentary, go to Gingrich360.com.
The views expressed in this article are the writer’s own.